St. Louis / Guides / Seafood

The best seafood restaurants in St. Louis.

Oysters, lobster rolls, crab legs and fried catfish across the St. Louis area, from South Broadway to Saint Charles and Madison, Illinois.

Best Seafood Restaurants in St. Louis (2026)
10 restaurants · 8 areasCompare the restaurants

Find your seafood restaurant.

Showing all 10 restaurants in ranking order.

About seafood in St. Louis

This list covers St. Louis seafood from a raw bar on South Broadway to a fish sandwich counter across the river in Madison, Illinois. The places split three ways: Gulf Coast and New England kitchens built around oysters, crab and lobster; steakhouses where the lobster and shrimp hold their own next to the beef; and fry houses where catfish and cod come out hot in cornmeal or batter. Each card names the three plates diners keep ordering and one practical tip, so the first visit goes right. Broadway Oyster Bar leads the list for its char-grilled oysters and New Orleans spirit, followed by Twisted Tree on Watson Road and Napoli Sea in Saint Charles.

The top picks: Broadway Oyster Bar, Twisted Tree, and Napoli Sea, with all 10 rooms ranked below.

Compare all 10 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
RestaurantNeighborhoodPriceScoreWhat to order
01 Broadway Oyster BarSt. Louis$$7.9Chargrilled Oysters
02 Twisted TreeSaint Louis$$$7.6Batter Dipped Lobster
03 Napoli SeaSaint Charles$$$7.6Seafood Risotto
04 Peacemaker Lobster & CrabSt. Louis$$7.4Lobster Roll
05 Extra WavySt. Louis$$7.3Lobster Donut
06 Sami's Southern KitchenSaint Peters$$7.1Catfish Fillets
07 J Gilbert'sDes Pers$$$7.0Maple Bourbon Shrimp
08 Marko's Fish HouseMadison$7.0Fish Sandwich
09 Oceano BistroClayton$$6.3Seafood Chowder
10 Bristol Seafood GrillCreve Coeur$$$6.0Lobster Bisque

10 restaurants · In guide order

01

Broadway Oyster Bar

Cajun/Creole · St. Louis · $$Back to filters

7.9Insider Score
Broadway Oyster BarYelp

Char-Grilled Oysters on South Broadway

Set on South Broadway a short walk from Busch Stadium, Broadway Oyster Bar brings a New Orleans spirit to St. Louis, with stickered walls, a stage for live bands and a patio with its own bar. Oysters come up in 73 of 200 diner reviews, raw on the half shell or char-grilled, and the char-grilled ones are the order several diners rank above New Orleans versions. Voodoo shrimp tacos and alligator cheesecake round out the table. The kitchen runs spicy by design.

Broadway Oyster Bar at 736 South Broadway sits a short walk from Busch Stadium, and diners hear it before they reach the door: music on the sidewalk, a crowd inside, stickers on every wall. The room has a bar, an indoor dining area and a patio with its own bar and stage, and the whole place leans into New Orleans.

Oysters are the order. They come raw on the half shell or char-grilled, and the char-grilled ones arrive hot and well seasoned, with several diners ranking them above versions they ate in New Orleans. Voodoo shrimp tacos are the next plate people reorder, and the alligator cheesecake is the dish first timers are talked into and then recommend. Shrimp and grits, gator bites and a shrimp po' boy fill out the table. The kitchen runs spicy on purpose.

Practical notes: parking is limited, with a small lot and paid street parking nearby, and it gets tight on Cardinals game days. A cover charge applies when a band is playing. Reservations help for groups.

Insider tip

Parking is limited and tight on Cardinals game days, and a cover charge applies when a band is playing.

What to order

Chargrilled Oysters, Voodoo Shrimp Tacos, Alligator Cheesecake

HoursDaily: 11:00 AM - 1:30 AM
Address736 S Broadway
Saint Louis, MO 63102
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Chargrilled Oysters

Arrive at the table hot and well seasoned, and several diners rank them above versions eaten in New Orleans.

Voodoo Shrimp Tacos

A spicy shrimp filling that diners reorder on return visits, and the same shrimp also comes as a po' boy.

Alligator Cheesecake

A savory cheesecake made with alligator that sounds odd to first timers and wins most of them over.

02

Twisted Tree

Seafood · Saint Louis · $$$Back to filters

7.6Insider Score
Twisted TreeYelp

Lobster Bites at a Watson Road Steakhouse

A steakhouse first, Twisted Tree on Watson Road sits next to a Holiday Inn, and the ribeye and prime rib get most of the attention. Seafood earns its place on the starter side of the menu. The batter dipped lobster comes as bites for the table or as a whole fried tail, and diners call it tender rather than chewy. Twisted shrimp arrive wrapped in bacon with dipping sauces, and the crab rangoon is crisp. Birthdays and anniversaries fill the room, and staff bring a slice of cake for celebrations.

Twisted Tree at 10701 Watson Road is a steakhouse attached to a Holiday Inn, with a rustic room that does not ask anyone to dress up. Ribeye, filet and prime rib carry most of the menu, and birthday and anniversary dinners fill the tables.

For seafood, start with the batter dipped lobster. It comes as bites for the table or as a full fried tail, and diners describe it as tender rather than chewy. The twisted shrimp are wrapped in bacon and served with dipping sauces, and the crab rangoon arrives crisp. Toasted brisket ravioli and the house salad are the other starters regulars mention. Staff bring a slice of cake when a celebration is noted on the reservation.

Practical notes: book a week or so ahead for prime dinner times, since the room is in demand. Valet is complimentary, which helps when the lot shared with the hotel is full. Happy hour runs daily at the bar with lower-priced appetizers and drinks, a good way to try the lobster bites without a full steak dinner.

Insider tip

Book a week or so ahead for prime dinner times, and use the complimentary valet when the shared hotel lot is full.

What to order

Batter Dipped Lobster, Twisted Shrimp, Crab Rangoon

HoursMon: ClosedTue - Sat: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSun: Closed
Address10701 Watson Rd
Saint Louis, MO 63127
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Batter Dipped Lobster

Tender rather than chewy, served as bites for the table or as a full fried tail with dinner.

Twisted Shrimp

Wrapped in bacon and served with dipping sauces, a starter diners order before the steaks arrive.

Crab Rangoon

Crisp and served with dipping sauces, a starter diners often share alongside the lobster bites.

03

Napoli Sea

Seafood · Saint Charles · $$$Back to filters

7.6Insider Score
Napoli SeaYelp

Tableside Risotto in Saint Charles

Napoli Sea on Beale Street in Saint Charles is a polished seafood room with a nautical feel, balanced between casual and fine dining, where servers walk diners through where each fish comes from. The seafood risotto is the showpiece, finished tableside in a giant cheese wheel. Chargrilled oysters and East Coast oysters on the half shell both draw praise, and the sea bass and halibut come out flaky and well cooked. Anniversaries and birthdays make up much of the crowd.

Napoli Sea at 1450 Beale Street in Saint Charles is a seafood room with a nautical feel and a tone that sits between casual and fine dining. Servers walk diners through the menu, including where each fish comes from and how it can be prepared, and some tables get to pick their fish.

The seafood risotto is the showpiece. It is finished tableside in a giant cheese wheel, and diners treat it as both dinner and a show. Chargrilled oysters are a favorite starter, and the raw East Coast oysters earn praise as some of the best in the St. Louis area. For an entree, the sea bass and the halibut with lemon butter sauce both come out flaky and well cooked. A seafood tower with oysters, shrimp, lobster and crab suits a group.

Practical notes: reserve ahead and mention any birthday or anniversary, since celebrations make up much of the crowd. Tables can run behind at busy times, and the bar is a comfortable place to wait with a cocktail.

Insider tip

Reserve ahead and mention any celebration; tables can run behind at busy times, so plan on a drink at the bar.

What to order

Seafood Risotto, Chargrilled Oysters, Sea Bass

HoursMon - Thu: 4:00 PM - 10:00 PMFri - Sat: 4:00 PM - 11:00 PMSun: 4:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Address1450 Beale St
St Charles, MO 63303
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Seafood Risotto

Prepared tableside in a giant cheese wheel, so it arrives as both dinner and a show for the table.

Chargrilled Oysters

Smoky and savory off the grill, and diners also rate the raw East Coast oysters among the best in the area.

Sea Bass

Flaky, rich and well seasoned, often served with mashed potatoes and asparagus on the side.

04

Peacemaker Lobster & Crab

Seafood · St. Louis · $$ · № 32 on the ListBack to filters

7.4Insider Score
Peacemaker Lobster & CrabYelp

Lobster Rolls Two Ways in Benton Park

Peacemaker Lobster & Crab on Sidney Street in Benton Park is the lobster roll address in St. Louis, and 79 of 200 diner reviews mention the lobster roll. It comes Maine style or Connecticut style, served warm with a dash of Old Bay, and diners split on which is better. Peel and eat shrimp, a raw bar with several oyster choices, and steamed crab legs served with a bucket of supplies fill out the table. The hush puppies are the side to add.

Peacemaker Lobster & Crab at 1831 Sidney Street in Benton Park is where St. Louis goes for a lobster roll. Diners order it Maine style or Connecticut style, served warm with a dash of Old Bay, and both come packed with generous chunks of lobster. Many tables split one of each.

The rest of the menu works the same coastline. Peel and eat shrimp is the standard starter, and the raw bar offers several oyster choices with house sauces and fresh horseradish. Steamed crab legs come with a bucket of supplies, including wet towels, shell buckets and lemon, and the lobster boil includes a full lobster with potatoes, corn and sausage. Hush puppies are the side diners keep praising, and a few call them the best they have had. The Lyonnaise salad has its own fans.

Practical notes: dinner fills the dining room and can bring a wait, so lunch or a seat at the bar is the easier route. A patio adds space in good weather.

Insider tip

Dinner fills the dining room and can bring a wait, so lunch or a seat at the bar is the easier route.

What to order

Lobster Roll, Peel and Eat Shrimp, Hush Puppies

HoursMon - Thu: 11:00 AM - 2:00 PM, 4:30 PM - 8:30 PMFri - Sat: 11:00 AM - 2:00 PM, 4:30 PM - 9:30 PMSun: 12:00 PM - 8:30 PM
Address1831 Sidney St
Saint Louis, MO 63104
Restaurant Reservations Call Directions
Map showing Peacemaker Lobster & Crab© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Lobster Roll

Offered Maine style or warm Connecticut style with a dash of Old Bay, both packed with generous chunks of lobster.

Peel and Eat Shrimp

Fresh and made for sharing, a starter diners pair with raw oysters from the bar.

Hush Puppies

A side several diners call the best they have had, and a pleasant surprise next to the seafood.

05

Extra Wavy

Seafood · St. Louis · $$Back to filters

7.3Insider Score
Extra WavyYelp

Lobster Donut on Chouteau Avenue

Playful is the word for Extra Wavy on Chouteau Avenue, with a whimsical room, a raw bar and small martinis for anyone after a taste rather than a full cocktail. The lobster donut is the signature, a savory lobster donut that diners pair with salt and vinegar fries. Scallop crudo and hamachi crudo lead the starters, and the lump crab pasta is rich and creamy. Small plates are the strength here, so a table does best ordering several to share.

Extra Wavy at 2017 Chouteau Avenue is the playful seafood stop in town, with a whimsical room, soft chairs and a crowd that keeps it lively even on weeknights. The cocktail list is part of the draw, including small martinis for anyone who wants a taste rather than a full drink.

The lobster donut is the signature, a savory donut with lobster that diners pair with the salt and vinegar fries. The raw bar and crudos lead the starters: the scallop crudo is thinly sliced and delicately presented, and the hamachi crudo is the one many tables add alongside it. The lump crab pasta is rich, creamy and filling. Baked oysters, lamb meatballs and pork belly skewers are other favorites, and the burger draws praise of its own.

Practical notes: small plates are the strength here, so a table does best ordering several to share. Reservations are strongly recommended for dinner and larger groups, though walk-ins have found seats at happy hour.

Insider tip

Reservations are strongly recommended for dinner and larger groups, though walk-ins have had luck at happy hour.

What to order

Lobster Donut, Scallop Crudo, Crab Pasta

HoursMon: ClosedTue - Sat: 5:00 PM - 10:00 PMSun: Closed
Address2017 Chouteau Ave
Saint Louis, MO 63103
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Lobster Donut

Savory rather than sweet, and best with an order of the salt and vinegar fries alongside.

Scallop Crudo

Thinly sliced and delicately presented; the portion is small, so many tables add the hamachi crudo too.

Crab Pasta

Rich, creamy and filling, made with lump crab, and a dish diners keep thinking about afterward.

06

Sami's Southern Kitchen

Seafood · Saint Peters · $$Back to filters

7.1Insider Score
Sami's Southern KitchenYelp

Cornmeal Catfish in Saint Peters

Out on Veterans Memorial Parkway in Saint Peters, Sami's Southern Kitchen is a fry house diners trust, and catfish comes up in 53 of 200 diner reviews. The fillets wear a seasoned cornmeal crust that stays crunchy outside and flaky inside, with no muddy taste. Catfish nuggets and hand breaded jumbo shrimp are the other orders, and Sami's house sauce goes on all of it. Portions are generous, the staff is warm, and the menu runs well past seafood into chicken, gumbo and red beans and rice.

Sami's Southern Kitchen at 4245 Veterans Memorial Parkway in Saint Peters is a Southern fry house, and catfish is what diners drive out for. The fillets come in a seasoned cornmeal crust that stays crunchy outside and flaky inside, with a clean taste and no muddiness. They are also offered grilled.

Catfish nuggets are the other favorite, best with Sami's house sauce, which diners say to order extra of. Hand breaded jumbo shrimp come on platters or on bread as a sandwich with fresh vegetables. Combination plates mix fried fish, shrimp and oysters, and the gumbo meal is big enough for two. Hush puppies, red beans and rice, fried okra and fried green tomatoes round out a long menu that also covers chicken and burgers.

Practical notes: portions are generous, so plan to share or carry some home. Takeout is handled well, and calling ahead for pickup works after work. Diners who eat in get full bottles of sauce at the table and a friendly, attentive staff.

Insider tip

Portions are big enough to share or carry home, and calling ahead for pickup works well after work.

What to order

Catfish Fillets, Catfish Nuggets, Jumbo Shrimp

HoursMon - Sat: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMSun: 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Address4245 Veterans Memorial Pkwy
Saint Peters, MO 63376
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Catfish Fillets

Fried golden in a seasoned cornmeal crust, crisp outside and flaky inside, and also offered grilled.

Catfish Nuggets

Bite-size and crunchy, best paired with the house sauce, which diners say to order extra of.

Jumbo Shrimp

Hand breaded and big, served on platters or on bread as a sandwich with fresh vegetables.

Advertisement
07

J Gilbert's

Seafood · Des Pers · $$$Back to filters

7.0Insider Score
J Gilbert'sYelp

Wood-Fired Steaks and Maple Shrimp

Wood-fired steaks are the draw at J Gilbert's at West County Center, and the filet is what most diners come for, but the seafood holds up next to it. The maple bourbon shrimp are large and glazed, the crab cake is a favorite partner in the filet combo, and lobster mac and cheese is the side diners tell each other to order. Chilean sea bass gets regular praise too. Warm sourdough arrives with flavored butters before the meal.

J Gilbert's at West County Center is a wood-fired steakhouse, and the filet is what most diners come for. The dining room suits couples, small groups and business dinners, and it fills with birthday and anniversary celebrations.

The seafood holds up next to the beef. Maple bourbon shrimp are large and glazed, served as an entree or added to a steak. The crab cake is the usual partner in the filet combo, often on a server's recommendation. Lobster mac and cheese is the side diners tell each other to order, and Chilean sea bass and maple bourbon salmon both earn praise. Oysters Rockefeller and calamari are on the starter list. Before the meal, a warm sourdough loaf arrives with flavored butters.

Practical notes: book ahead for celebrations, since the room is popular for them. Happy hour brings lower-priced oysters and is a lighter way in. The restaurant sits right outside the mall, which makes it an easy stop after shopping.

Insider tip

Book ahead for birthdays and anniversaries, and watch for happy hour, when oysters come at a lower price.

What to order

Maple Bourbon Shrimp, Lobster Mac and Cheese, Crab Cake

HoursMon - Thu: 4:00 PM - 9:00 PMFri - Sat: 4:00 PM - 10:00 PMSun: 3:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Address17A W County Ctr
Frontenac, MO 63131
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Maple Bourbon Shrimp

Large and maple glazed, served as an entree or added to a steak as a surf and turf plate.

Lobster Mac and Cheese

A side diners rank among the best versions they have had, and a common pairing with the filet.

Crab Cake

Often chosen as the second half of the filet combo on a server's recommendation, and also offered as a starter.

08

Marko's Fish House

Seafood · Madison · $Back to filters

7.0Insider Score
Marko's Fish HouseYelp

Cod Sandwich Worth Crossing the River

Across the river on Madison Avenue in Madison, Illinois, Marko's Fish House is the reason to drive to the Metro East, and 95 of 200 diner reviews mention the fish sandwich. It is Icelandic cod fried to order in a house batter, no cornmeal, on soft Italian bread with pickles, onions and banana peppers. Fried mushrooms, potato salad and coleslaw are the sides. Seating is a few stools and tables, and most orders go out the door.

Marko's Fish House at 820 Madison Avenue in Madison, Illinois, sits across the river in the Metro East, and the fish sandwich is the reason to make the drive. Diners describe a simple menu done well: cod sandwiches, shrimp and sides, cooked to order.

The sandwich is Icelandic cod in a house batter, no cornmeal, served on soft, locally sourced Italian bread with pickles, onions and banana peppers. Diners who have eaten fish sandwiches across the country rank it at the top. Fried mushrooms are the side people did not expect to like as much as they do, and the potato salad and coleslaw are homemade. Some diners pile the coleslaw and a slice of cheese right onto the sandwich. Homemade tartar sauce comes alongside.

Practical notes: diners say it is cash only and keeps limited hours, so check the schedule before driving over. Seating is a few stools and tables, and most orders go out as carryout, which can be called in ahead.

Insider tip

Diners say it is cash only with limited hours, so check the schedule, bring cash and call ahead for carryout.

What to order

Fish Sandwich, Fried Mushrooms, Potato Salad

HoursMon: ClosedTue - Thu: 11:00 AM - 6:00 PMFri: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PMSat - Sun: Closed
Address820 Madison Ave
Madison, IL 62060
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Fish Sandwich

Icelandic cod fried to order in a house batter and served on Italian cream bread with pickles and onions.

Fried Mushrooms

Crisp and fried to order, the side diners did not expect to enjoy as much as the fish.

Potato Salad

Homemade and well liked, sharing the table with a coleslaw that some diners pile straight onto the sandwich.

09

Oceano Bistro

Seafood · Clayton · $$Back to filters

6.3Insider Score
Oceano BistroYelp

Chowder and Lobster Tails in Clayton

Oceano Bistro on North Brentwood Boulevard in Clayton covers a lot of the day: lunch, brunch, dinner and a happy hour some diners call one of the strongest in town. Seafood chowder is the starter regulars recommend. At dinner, the North Atlantic lobster tails come with roasted potatoes and green beans, and the grilled salmon arrives wrapped in bacon over a potato cake. Brunch opens with a complimentary cinnamon roll, and the Oceano omelette is filled with scallops and rock shrimp.

Oceano Bistro at 44 North Brentwood Boulevard in Clayton covers the whole day: lunch, brunch, dinner and a happy hour that diners rate among the strongest in town. Shoppers from Old Town Clayton stop in for drinks and appetizers, and the staff greets regulars and newcomers alike.

Seafood chowder is the starter regulars recommend. At dinner, the North Atlantic lobster tails come as a pair with roasted potatoes, green beans and melted butter. The grilled salmon is wrapped in bacon and served over an arugula potato cake with a grain mustard cider jus. A shellfish platter with king crab suits a table that wants to share, and the crab cakes are full of crab. Desserts include bread pudding and layered cheesecake.

Practical notes: brunch starts with a complimentary cinnamon roll, and the Oceano omelette is filled with scallops and rock shrimp. Saturday runs the brunch menu rather than full lunch. Happy hour draws a crowd at the bar, and calling ahead helps for larger groups.

Insider tip

Happy hour draws a crowd at the bar, and Saturday still runs the brunch menu rather than a full lunch.

What to order

Seafood Chowder, Lobster Tails, Grilled Salmon

HoursMon - Thu: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMFri: 11:00 AM - 11:00 PMSat: 10:00 AM - 11:00 PMSun: 10:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Address44 N Brentwood Blvd
Clayton, MO 63105
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Seafood Chowder

A starter that comes highly recommended by staff and regulars, and diners say it lives up to that.

Lobster Tails

Served as a pair of tails with roasted potatoes, green beans and melted butter on the side.

Grilled Salmon

Wrapped in bacon over an arugula potato cake with a grain mustard cider jus.

10

Bristol Seafood Grill

Seafood · Creve Coeur · $$$Back to filters

6.0Insider Score
Bristol Seafood GrillYelp

Lobster Bisque on Olive Boulevard

Bristol Seafood Grill on Olive Boulevard in Creve Coeur has a classic, upscale room and a full slate of service: dinner, happy hour and a Sunday brunch some diners rank among the best in town. Warm biscuits with honey butter arrive before the meal. The lobster bisque is the most praised dish, creamy and full of flavor. Miso glazed sea bass is the entree diners compare to far pricier kitchens, and the crab cakes are a longtime house order.

Bristol Seafood Grill at 11801 Olive Boulevard in Creve Coeur has a classic, upscale room and a staff that regulars ask for by name. It runs dinner, happy hour and a Sunday brunch that some diners rank among the best in town.

Warm biscuits with honey butter arrive before the meal, and refills keep coming. The lobster bisque is the most praised dish on the menu, creamy and full of flavor, though the serving is small. Miso glazed sea bass is the entree diners compare to miso fish at far pricier restaurants, and the sea bass and swordfish both earn praise as fresh. Crab cakes are the house order servers recommend, best with the cauliflower au gratin. Oysters Rockefeller and crispy calamari lead the starters, and lobster and chips is a richer option.

Practical notes: Sunday brunch lets diners eat as much as they like. Happy hour starts in the late afternoon and suits a lighter visit, while birthday dinners are common at night, so reserve ahead for those.

Insider tip

Sunday brunch lets diners eat as much as they like, and happy hour starts in the late afternoon for a lighter visit.

What to order

Lobster Bisque, Miso Glazed Sea Bass, Crab Cakes

HoursMon - Thu: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMFri: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSat: 4:00 PM - 10:00 PMSun: 10:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Address11801 Olive Blvd
Creve Coeur, MO 63141
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Lobster Bisque

Creamy and full of flavor, though the serving runs small, so it works best as a starter.

Miso Glazed Sea Bass

Glazed with miso and served over mashed potatoes, an entree diners compare to miso fish at pricier restaurants.

Crab Cakes

Recommended by servers as a house specialty, and good with the cauliflower au gratin on the side.

Seafood questions, answered.

What is the best seafood restaurant in St. Louis?
Broadway Oyster Bar on South Broadway, a short walk from Busch Stadium, is the number one pick. Diners come for the char-grilled oysters, which several of them rank above versions they have eaten in New Orleans, plus raw oysters, voodoo shrimp tacos and alligator cheesecake. The patio, the live music and the New Orleans spirit make it a full night out.
Where can I find good seafood near me in St. Louis County?
Three strong choices sit in the county. Oceano Bistro on North Brentwood Boulevard in Clayton serves seafood chowder, lobster tails and a weekend brunch. Bristol Seafood Grill on Olive Boulevard in Creve Coeur is known for lobster bisque and miso glazed sea bass. J Gilbert's at West County Center pairs wood-fired steaks with maple bourbon shrimp and crab cakes.
Where is the best lobster roll in St. Louis?
Peacemaker Lobster & Crab on Sidney Street in Benton Park is the lobster roll address, offered Maine style or warm Connecticut style with a dash of Old Bay. For something different, Extra Wavy on Chouteau Avenue serves a savory lobster donut that diners pair with salt and vinegar fries.
Where can I get fried catfish or a fish sandwich around St. Louis?
Sami's Southern Kitchen on Veterans Memorial Parkway in Saint Peters fries catfish fillets and catfish nuggets in a seasoned cornmeal crust, with generous portions. Across the river, Marko's Fish House on Madison Avenue in Madison, Illinois, serves a cod sandwich on Italian bread with pickles and onions. Diners say Marko's is cash only, so bring cash.

The data first, then the verdict

We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →

About the writer
Lejla Begic
Staff Writer, Top of St. Louis

Staff Writer. Born in Sarajevo, raised in Bevo Mill, lives in Affton. Covers the guides and drives the whole metro to do it, from the Delmar Loop to the Metro East. Tells you the order, the price, the wait, and the parking.

A new place to try.

The Tip Sheet brings restaurant recommendations to your inbox.